Recent Posts

35 Mind Blowing Facts About America That Previous Generations Of Americans Never Would Have Believed

 MICHAEL SNYDER — Freedom Outpost The only thing that seems to be constant in our society is change, and today America is changing ...

Read More

A Close Look at the New Radical Muslim Agenda in America

                American Liberty Report Have you heard? Congress has more women serving right now than ever before! Apparently, that’s because America is ...

Read More

Image credit: Wikimedia Commons | CC BY 2.0

AOC's Green New Deal Is a U.S. Version of Mao’s Disastrous Great Leap Forward

Support for this proposal demonstrates a profound ignorance of even basic economic concepts. Image credit: Wikimedia Commons | CC BY 2.0 By ...

Read More

Trump’s Agenda Is a Winning Formula for Black America

By Star Parker                                                         @ The Daily Signal My fellow Americans. Given that the Democratic Party chose to select a recently defeated political candidate ...

Read More

Why Affordable Housing Is So Hard to Find in America’s Big Cities

To make housing affordable, policymakers need to remove the things that are making it unaffordable now: excessive regulations. By John Phelan                ...

Read More

Green Is the New Red – From Capitalism to Socialism

By Stephen Moore | cnsnews WASHINGTON, DC - FEBRUARY 07: U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) speaks as Sen. Ed Markey (D-MA) (R) and ...

Read More

Green New Deal More Proof Left Intends to ‘Fundamentally Transform’ US

Cal Thomas / @CalThomas / The Daily Signal Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's, D-N.Y., Green New Deal is just one example of how once-extreme ideas ...

Read More

What Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Could Learn from G.K. Chesterton

Once in power, democratic socialists cease to be democratic.   By Chuck Chalberg                                            @fee.org G. K. Chesterton (1874-1936) and H. L. Mencken (1880-1956) ...

Read More

Democrats Release Green New Deal. Here’s What’s in It.

By Michael Bastasch                                       of The Daily Signal New York Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez released a resolution that outlines the “Green New Deal” ...

Read More

There’s Nothing New About the Green New Deal

Jarrett Stepman / @JarrettStepman / The Daily Signal Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., and Sen. Ed Markey, D-Mass., right, announce their Green New Deal resolution ...

Read More

Latest News

[smoothslider]

Education. Comparing PA to other states.

Share

By Ron Beitler at RonBeitler.com

Ron Beitler

I’m probably nuts for writing about education cause it’s a hyper-partisan mine-field littered with special interests and an ingrained “team mentality”. As a township commissioner I have no influence on these conversations. I have no team and I’m not interested in joining one. I just want to step outside the echo chambers for a minute.

But here goes nothing. I try hard to remain agnostic. Step away from the partisanship and just look at the big picture. To that end, you can somewhat do so since in our American education system we have 49 relatively independent systems to compare. I always go back to how are we doing vs. other states as a baseline. In the US we have 50 laboratories to study.

I also understand that the broke system we have today has in the past affected the township. This is because as we scramble to apply band-aids to a system overly reliant on local taxing bodies to sustain the unsustainable by chasing ratables we’ve made some awful land use decisions “for the school district”.  As I often say it’s a rob Peter to pay Paul mentality. Low value development gives the district a band-aid windfall but hurts the township financially long term. But that’s what we get when we are constantly playing catch up. You can’t even blame the district for what is a rationale response to a broke system.

So how do we fix it? First some things I know based on comparing our system to other states: (determining baselines) Often we look at PA in a vacuum. To me that is an irrelevant exercise that only serves the status quo. To do so when we have the ability to benchmark against 49 other states makes no sense.

1. Pennsylvania is among the tops in total education spending. Meaning we have one of the most expensive systems in the nation. (29 Billion dollars)

Full stop.

Again, we have one of the most expensive systems in the nation. Pennsylvania today also has some of the highest paid teachers in the nation. Not saying good or bad. I’m just saying what is.

2. Pennsylvania has one of the highest per pupil spends. (Around 15k per child)

3. But, we have one of the worse ratios of local to state contributions. Less than 40% of our ed funds come from the state. Meaning the rest comes from local taxing bodies. This is a huge issue that band-aids will not fix.

4. We also have an incredibly inequitable system. With our current broken funding formula poorest districts are hurt the most.

5. Based on education efficiency ratings, Pennsylvania is middle of the pack. Efficiency ratings measure outcomes compared to dollars spent per pupil. In other words, we spend among the most as a state but with middling results.

Based on these five items what is clear to me is Pennsylvania does not have a revenue problem. Therefore the solution should not involve the nations highest net tax increase which is the Wolf proposal. That is a solution unrelated to a problem.

picture for beitler article

Other things I know: While we do not have a revenue problem, we definitely have a funding equality problem. Both state to local ratio but also district to district. We might also have a “bang for our buck” problem meaning a correlation problem. Higher spending does not necessarily mean better outcomes. There are other states that spend far less money and have far better outcomes. The Wolf budget ignores the structural problems that lead to our overly expensive (based on efficiency) system and doubles down on revenue. More and more and more money always.

There are literally a half dozen priorities that are more important than revenue. Revenue relating to total spend is NOT the problem in Pennsylvania. But there are things Democrats are demanding that I haven’t heard Republicans willing to address. Cyber Charter reform is one example. As I’ve said in other posts I dip my toes into this topic from a viewpoint that both parties seem to have masters they are unwilling to upset. That’s a political problem we have to overcome. As I’ve also said I would support a severance tax on extraction of a state natural resource (a resource that we have a PA constitutional obligation to protect) but only if it directly relates to property tax reduction on a revenue neutral dollar to dollar basis. Meaning shifting shifting away from homeowners. What we have on the table in the Governors budget is very simply the nations most extreme tax grab with some shell game property tax reduction.

Bottom line is structural reform means changes to the system. Not band-aids, not stop gaps, not windfalls but fundamental changes. Looking at things that are broken and fixing them. They can be transformative but also can be subtle.

Let’s get out of the echo chamber and find the middle ground.

 

Comments are closed.

Polls

Please take our reader satisfaction poll. Please select one from each part.

View Results