Latest News

Recent Posts
Police officer slain near Pittsburgh is ID’d; gunman still at large

Police officer slain near Pittsburgh is ID'd; gunman still at large

Fox News Police search for suspect after Pennsylvania officer killed Officer was fatally shot near Pittsburgh. A manhunt was underway in western Pennsylvania ...

Read More

After Agent’s Death, Trump Declares US ‘Must Build the Wall!’

Fred Lucas / @FredLucasWH /The Daily Signal A Border Patrol vehicle guards a section of border fence in Runn, Texas, in this March ...

Read More

How Hungary Cut Illegal Immigration by 99%

By Matt | Contributor/The Political Insider What better way to figure out how to combat illegal immigration than to look at other countries that ...

Read More

Newlin Township to Receive $754,000 Grant

Weekly Roundup Friday, November 17, 2017 The latest news from the State Capitol Newlin Township to Receive $754,000 Grant I am happy to announce ...

Read More

Bernstine Announces Safe Schools Grants for Laurel School District, Lawrence County Vo-Tech

Representative Aaron Bernstine 10th Legislative District Pennsylvania House of Representatives   RepBernstine.com / Facebook.com/RepBernstine   FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE November 17, 2017   Bernstine Announces Safe Schools Grants for Laurel School District, ...

Read More

Meet These 5 Stellar Conservatives Trump Just Added to His Supreme Court List

John G. Malcolm / @malcolm_john / Elizabeth Slattery / @EHSlattery / Tiffany Bates / @TiffanyHBates / The Daily Signal President Donald Trump on Friday added five judges to his list ...

Read More

Americans for Limited Government Press Release

ALG urges confirmation of Trump nominees November 17, 2017 by press   Nov. 17, 2017, Fairfax, Va.—Americans for Limited Government President Rick Manning ...

Read More

Jeff Sessions fighting gun crimes when Obama refused

By Natalia Castro at NetRight Daily and Americans for Limited Government Republicans and Democrats alike can agree that safety must be ...

Read More

Watch: 58 Seconds Guaranteed to Give Obama a Heart Attack

BY BENJAMIN ARIE/CT Just under one minute of footage from a coal mine in West Virginia has managed to put Barack Obama, ...

Read More

Hate Crimes Data: Similar Numbers, Different Percentages

FBI hate crime data shows little change in the number of crimes, but significant changes in race of offenders. By the ...

Read More

Letter Writer has issue with speed cameras in work zones

Share

 

Dear Lehigh Valley Commentator:

The Senate Press Release on speed cameras in work zones is short on factual information.

There is no epidemic of speeding and no crisis of highway workers being mowed down by crazed drivers run amok, contrary to what the Legislators and vested interests want you to believe.

Recent federal statistics are being used as a bait and switch. We’re supposed to think highway workers are at risk, but they’re not — 82% of the deaths are drivers, not workers.

But what’s left unsaid is that the majority of worker deaths are caused by work zone equipment, not by drivers. You only get the data for that by digging into the accident reports. Incidentally, the Maryland speed camera program is an abject failure rife with inaccuracies and corruption.

Pennsylvania politicians who stand to benefit are calling for speed cameras for traffic violations in highway work zones in order to gain a predictable flood of revenue into Harrisburg. That, in spite of the fact that 25% of the PennDOT workers killed in work zone fatalities were due to passing civilian vehicles since 1970. Through 2014, that is 21 fatalities by passing vehicles in 45 years, or one about every 2.14 years. No way were 16 killed this year as the article says.

Blatantly false and misleading data is provided by PennDOT, the camera makers and their lobbyists, and the rest of the automated enforcement vested interests who desperately want speed cameras to fatten their bottom line at the expense of safe driving motorists. The politicians are only too happy to help their industry friends because it results in maintaining a constant stream of money flowing into Harrisburg for general funding.

The true data shows that 75% of the PennDOT workers killed were accidents with other workers or work machinery. If PennDOT actually wants a program to reduce the number of PennDOT workers killed, wouldn’t it make sense to go after the 64, or 75%, killed inside the work zones by other workers first? Yet, our esteemed public servants propose what PennDOT wants, and the camera interests have now recruited the APC and PHIA to jump on the disinformation bandwagon and endorse an expensive technology that has proven to be ineffective at making roads safer.
On top of that, speed cameras failed to produce any significant safety results in a Minnesota DOT work zone study.
http://thenewspaper.com/news/50/5006.asp

 “Traffic Camera Lobbyists Buy Victory in Maryland Legislature”
“Four photo ticketing firms spend $555,106 in campaign donations and lobbying for $9.8 million statewide speed camera payoff in Maryland.”
http://thenewspaper.com/news/27/2752.asp I would bet the same process is being rolled out in Pennsylvania, because there is no need for speed cameras EXCEPT TO RAISE REVENUE!

 Transportation Officials Using Bogus Worker Death Data: Inflated worker death numbers used to implement double fine programs that have no proven beneficial safety effect
http://www.thenewspaper.com/news/07/729.asp?winst=1503771825850&of=0

 Minnesota Study Finds No Benefit To Work Zone Speed Cams: Speed cameras failed to produce any significant results in a Minnesota DOT work zone study
http://www.thenewspaper.com/news/50/5006.asp?winst=1503771825850&of=0

 All the unbiased evidence, that is, evidence from groups or people who make no money off cameras, is that the cameras don’t work, and that they are only for money, not for safety.

The pro-automated-tax people are going after work zone safety in a poor way, one that is more likely to raise significant amounts of money than to actually improve safety. Reject speed cameras in Pennsylvania highway work zones. Re-engineer the work zones for safety instead.

To be fair to your readers, in your next piece about speed cameras please include the above. Thank you.

Sincerely,
Tom McCarey Member, National Motorists Association
www.motorists.org

Featured Video

Local Issues

Voices of the People

Your Schools

Issues

Letters to the Editor

More from our archives