Recent Posts
B56536_BETHSINGER_FLAG

Dead Men Tell No Tales in Broward County: 3 Recent Whistleblowers Who Ended Up DEAD

Opening your mouth in Debbie Wasserman Schultz’s district has been proven to be quite hazardous to one’s health.  DEAN GARRISON — Freedom Outpost For ...

Read More

According To NBC Nearly 200,000 Registered Florida Voters Were Non-Citizens In 2012- It’s Anybody’s Guess How Many There are in Broward County Today

Corruption 10/American Journal Review In 2012, the NBC affiliate in Miami quoted Florida officials as saying that nearly 200,000 registered voters in the state may not ...

Read More

Fraud? Several Georgia Counties Reporting Thousands of New Votes. Cut GOP Lead.

BY CILLIAN ZEAL /WJ Just remember: You can never, ever call counting votes that mysteriously appear out of nowhere “voter fraud.” The number of ...

Read More

CAUGHT ON VIDEO: FL Democrat Party Attorney Tells Laura Loomer – DESTROYING BALLOTS ISN’T FRAUD

Democrats, Politics 5/American Journal Review CAUGHT ON VIDEO: FL Democrat Party Attorney Tells Laura Loomer – DESTROYING BALLOTS ISN’T FRAUD. Leonard Samuels, a Florida Democrat lawyer, ...

Read More

Will the Florida recounts put democracy at risk?

By Donald Wilfong at the Daily Torch In the Great State of Florida, there is a current outbreak of rampant voter ...

Read More

The Math: It's Almost Certain That Rick Scott and Ron DeSantis Have Won in Florida

By Guy Benson at Townhall Amid the violations of law by Broward and Palm Beach County elections officials, the data provides apparent ...

Read More

Treasury Can’t Go Wobbly When Sanctions Against Russians Are Starting to Hurt

Luke Coffey / @LukeDCoffey /The Daily Signal Russian President Vladimir Putin attends an event marking the 25th anniversary of Russia’s electoral system ...

Read More

Watch Trump Flip The Script On Liberal Reporter Who Tried To Blame Him For Political Violence

American Journal Review When one liberal reporter accused President Donald Trump of encouraging supporters to carry out acts of violence against ...

Read More

Rep. Nadler: 'We Will Certainly Pursue Sensible Gun Control Legislation'

By Susan Jones | cnsnews Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-N.Y.) speaks during a House Judiciary Subcommittee hearing on February 27, 2018. (Photo by Drew ...

Read More

BANG! AMMO MAKER SUES DICK'S SPORTING GOODS

From WND Seeks damages for breach of contract, negligent misrepresentation   A supplier to Dick’s Sporting Goods is suing the nationwide chain for ...

Read More

Latest News

[smoothslider]

Senate and House Leaders Challenge PA Supreme Court Redistricting

Share

 

 

Representative Mike Turzai

Speaker of the House

28th District

Pennsylvania House of Representatives

Media Contact: Neal Lesher

717.260.6495 (office) 717.507.9240 (cell)

NLesher@pahousegop.com

RepTurzai.com / Facebook.com/RepTurzai / Twitter.com/RepTurzai

 

OP-ED FOR CONSIDERATION

February 21, 2018

 

Redistricting Op-Ed by Speaker of the House Mike Turzai

 

Sen. Joe Scarnati, as the Pennsylvania Senate Pro Tempore, and I, as Speaker of the Pennsylvania House, filed an Emergency Application for a Stay with the United States Supreme Court today. Our application makes clear that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court did not have the power to invalidate the constitutional, democratically passed congressional map. In allowing the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to invalidate federal congressional lines and to draw lines of their own, the U.S. Supreme Court will allow chaos to ensue throughout the United States in the coming years where politically connected litigants can go running into state Supreme Courts to invalidate congressional maps. These litigants will do so to stop legislative agendas with which they do not agree.

 

Please note that the Pennsylvania House of Representatives passed the 2011 Pennsylvania congressional map by a vote of 136-61, with 100 Republicans voting “yes” and 36 Democrats voting “yes.” Passing the bill requires 102 votes. This map was the result of bipartisan work between representatives elected by their constituents.

 

We have now used the existing maps for three straight elections. It wasn’t until President Donald Trump was elected that a flurry of liberal activists began challenging congressional maps across the country, including Pennsylvania.

 

Keep in mind that a three-judge federal court panel in the Agre case upheld the 2011 Pennsylvania congressional map as constitutional with respect to the U.S. Constitution on Jan. 10. Less than two weeks later, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court invalidated the 2011 Pennsylvania congressional map on the basis of the state constitution – which has no explicit language addressing the drawing of congressional district lines. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court did this on a partisan 5-2 Democrat-to-Republican split. One of the justices actually campaigned on invalidating the Pennsylvania congressional map before being elected to the bench.

 

In the Feb. 21 edition of The Wall Street Journal, the editors opined in a piece entitled “Pennsylvania’s Redistricting Coup.”  The editorial concludes,

 

“Republicans plan to ask federal courts to enjoin the map, as they should.  The U.S. High Court last month declined a request to intervene, perhaps giving deference to state judges’ interpretation of state law.  But the judge-drawn map violates the U.S. Constitution’s Elections Clause, which provides that “[t]he Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof.

 

“State judges can’t usurp the legislature’s authority over redistricting willy-nilly. The Supreme Court ought to block this judicial coup d’etat, but be warned. Pennsylvania will be the future in every state if the Justices decide that judges should be redistricting kings.”

 

Comments are closed.

Polls

Please take our reader satisfaction poll. Please select one from each part.

View Results