Recent Posts

Donald Trump: At Least We’re Not Paying North Korea $150 billion Like the Iran Deal

AP Photos Breitbart News Network/ Charlie Spiering President Donald Trump defended his agreement with North Korea compared to the Iran Deal reached by ...

Read More

Mainstream Media Calls Trump-Kim Summit a Failure

~ Liberty Democrats and their fake news media buddies have gone on the offensive in an effort to undermine the historic ...

Read More

ICYMI: House Passes Bill to Ensure Economic Development Programs in Appalachia Can Be Used to Fight Opioid Epidemic

Washington, D.C. - The U.S. House of Representatives today overwhelmingly approved the Treating Barriers to Prosperity Act of 2018 (H.R. ...

Read More

The Silent Suffering of Fathers After Abortion

Victoria Robinson / The Daily Signal "These men still taste the bitterness and pain of their abortion. It’s always there," ...

Read More

She’s Back! Stripper Abortionist with Arrest Record Returns to Delta Abortion Clinic in Disguise

 By Operation Rescue 9 Comments By Cheryl Sullenger at Operation Rescue Baton Rouge, LA – Nsikan M. St. Martin wasn’t supposed to be working at the Delta ...

Read More

ICYMI: Barletta USA Today Op-Ed on School Security

We in Congress should protect students from gun violence as well as we protect ourselves After the 2017 congressional baseball shooting, ...

Read More

Rep. Smucker's E-Update

HOME ABOUT CONTACT MEDIA SERVICES Thank you for subscribing to my E-Newsletter! This week I want to update you on passage of my legislation to ...

Read More

Reaching for Four-Percent Growth: Trump’s Economy

Written by Joe Scudder/EagleRising The economy is almost experiencing four-percent growth despite economists saying that it would be lower! A year ago even ...

Read More

Fired-Up Trump Names the Only 3 Things Democrats Are Good At

BY BEN MARQUIS /WJ President Donald Trump took to Twitter Saturday morning to sidestep the liberal media and speak directly to the American ...

Read More

FEWER OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE DEMOCRATS TO CHEAT

 COMMON CONSTITUTIONALIST/ Godfather Politics.  THE DEMOCRATS ARE FINDING IT HARDER TO CHEAT… AND BOY IS THE LEFT NOT HAPPY ABOUT IT. Voting in elections ...

Read More

Latest News

[smoothslider]

RADAR is unreliable–says letter writer

Share

RADAR is unreliable. Lawyers, take note*.

In this election year, the Legislature should VOTE NO on Speed Trap Bill SB 251, authorizing RADAR for municipal police, because RADAR speed measurement is unreliable.

The courts regard radar as foolproof. Nothing further from the truth. Fresh evidence that further erodes radar’s patina of infallibility comes from an American Academy of Forensic Sciences research presentation titled “Testing of Police RADAR”. The research was conducted by two professional engineers, one of whom previously worked for a RADR manufacturer.

Despite 30 years of technological innovations, RADAR still suffers from the same reliability and performance issues that have made it unacceptable as evidence in a court of law. RADAR cannot meet the requirements of the Daubert test*, the set of standards trial judges use to determine whether or not expert testimony is based on valid scientific reasoning and methodology:

“The reality of police radar is that it fails when subjected to the Daubert test. In this regard, police RADAR operation should be repeatable—this research demonstrates that it is not a repeatable technique and is, in fact, subject to operator interpretation when multiple targets are present.”

The researchers tested several radar unit brands and units. With only one target, the units were pretty consistent in their speed measurements. However with multiple targets, there was no guarantee as to which vehicle’s speed was displayed. They observe that “the radar units can well read different speeds … the decision to issue a citation is highly dependent upon the operator, relative to the instrument.” This refers to one of RADAR’s biggest downfalls: it can’t distinguish one vehicle from another.

The researchers further explain that RADAR can pick out either the strongest signal or the fastest signal, depending on road conditions and the mix of vehicles on the road. It cannot, however, pick out the speed of the nearest vehicle. They point out that RADAR “gun sights” intended to aid target acquisition are useless.

The researchers had the presence of mind to point out that RADAR speed enforcement encourages policing for profit. Which is the Legislature’s prime motivation to pass Speed Trap Bill SB 251.

Overall, the study further supports the conclusion that RADAR speed measurement is unreliable, easily misused and often abused for revenue purposes. Which it certainly will be in Pennsylvania.

Sincerely,

Tom McCarey Member, Pennsylvania Chapter of the National Motorists Association
The opinions expressed in this letter belong to the author and do not necessarily represent those of the NMA or the NMA Foundation

Comments are closed.

Polls

Please take our reader satisfaction poll. Please select one from each part.

View Results